Leave it to Brooke White to leave American Idol and forget the lyrics on the swan song. Finally she is gone!
BTW she should go on Fox’s Don’t Forget the Lyrics because at least there they have the lyrics on a teleprompter for her, and I bet even then she would still forget the lyrics.
Thank gosh for Paula Abdul because without her American Idol would be boring. Last night’s American Idol might have crammed 10 Neil Diamond songs into one hour, but it was so boring I forgot who sang what and I don’t care what they did.
But back to Paula that was evil of American Idol to put so much pressure on her, they know she can’t handle it! But thankfully they did because her craziness is always blogworthy!!! Unlike Jason Castro and Brooke White’s performances. Hopefully Brooke will go home tonight because I still think it is BS she is still on after forgetting the lyrics last week.
BTW maybe because I actually hit puberty, can someone please explain what is so amazing about David Archuleta? I thought his America was emotionless.
Oh yeah I am a sincerely a Neil Diamond fan and there is not one song I remotely liked last night.
Who is voting for Brooke White? She should have been eliminated for forgetting the words as soon as she did so, but I guess her fans disagree. And there seems to be a lot more of them than there is me.
BTW next week they are doing the songs of Neil Diamond. I am curious to see how that goes down on next week's American Idol. I would be shocked if Jason Castro didn't do UB40's version of Red Red Wine. And you know David Archuleta's stage dad is loving the theme, he has so much to choose from for his little money maker! I am also curious to see what David Cook makes haunting because he should own the night once again!!!
Sacreligious. I cannot remember any other time that a contestant has stopped American Idol and asked for a do over because they forgot the lyrics. People are eliminated in the Hollywood and she made it to the top 6! I say You must hate her! Her chances on American Idol show be the same as Eva Peron’s fate at the end of the play. Disgraceful.
Now when it comes to the rest…
How the freak did Jason Castro gets Memories? I wish I could forget that performance, but it went on so long it is etched into my memory.
David Archuleta so messed up, he had the golden opportunity to make a niche for himself as the next Michael Crawford and he went with a female’s song.
Syeshia surprised me because she was enjoyable and so was Carly Smithson. If Carly didn’t have that tattoo sleeve she could have a career on Broadway.
And my boy David Cook was good, but I not sure he was the Music of the Night.
So who should go home? Brooke White. In fact I say do away with the bottom 3 and just eliminate her. Let her be put on the Idol stake for that!
BTW SirAndrew LLoyd Webber was a great and honest mentor!
Right now there are Broadway producers rejoicing over tonight's theme Andrew Lloyd Webber on Fox's American Idol at 8p. Since Frenchie Davis stepped on to the RENT stage, Broadway has become home to several American Idol contestants like Fantasia, Clay Aiken, Diana DeGarmo and Constantine Maroulis to name a few. But never in the show's 7 year history has American Idol catered to show tunes. Well that all changes tonight when Andrew Lloyd Webber mentors the remaining 6! Why do I have the feeling we are going to get a lot of Cats and The Phantom of the Opera and not enough Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat and Evita???
David Cook would do well with something from Phantom because it is so dark. Syeshia will probably do Memories because she always chooses songs bigger than her. Jason Castro will probably do something from Jesus Christ Superstar because it is him. Carly and Brooke should do something for Joseph or Evita, but they will with either do songs from Cats or Phantom. And finally David Archuleta has to do something from Phantom because that is his calling…Michael Crawford 2!
Hopefully tonight will not disappoint because I am actually looking forward to it!
